How Did I Hate the New Dark Shadows Movie? Let me count the ways.
First, I need to point out that I co-wrote a book on Dark Shadows called the Dark Shadows Companion. I’m a first-generation fan. I’m one of those who ran home from school to see it. I am the audience that Depp and Burton will need to reach to reboot the franchise. I have bad news for them. They just spit in the face of a big portion of the audience. I ran home from school, my friends, and I didn’t give a tinker’s damn about the triangle Barnabas/Josette/Angelique storyline that Depp-Burton focused on.
The whole show, for me, was about Julia and Barnabas. It was bad enough that the film turns Julia into an alcoholic (something she NEVER was on the series), but they show her smoking a cigarette. Yes, given what Grayson died of, I find this an incredibly bad creative choice, but I suppose that’s subjective nitpicking. HBC watched enough episodes to pick up a couple of her mannerisms, but that’s where the resemblance ends. Julia’s wardrobe is Mode o’Day if their fashion buyer was Bozo the Clown.
What they did was turn Barnabas into her murderer and utterly destroy their relationship as far as their franchise is concerned. Dark Shadows, at its worst, was about all the women obsessing on the vampire. From the end of the film and its stupid Godzilla ending, it’s clear they’re wanting to bring Julia back as a vampire to be the new villain, something she was for a brief time on the series.
Burton and Depp may as well burn the script for that one. They’ve already lost most of the Julia fans. I know they lost me. Admittedly, they barely had my interest to begin with, but yeesh …
As an independent film, I found it weird as hell. Visually, it wasn’t Collinsport for me. It was sort of Disneyland Collinsport. Collinwood itself looked like the Haunted Mansion at Disneyland. The woodlands looked like England, not Maine, which seemed as out-of-place as Beverly Hills did when Curtis used it for Collinwood in the 1991 series. The few bits I liked (Barnabas crashing on the rocks but not dying) were quickly overtaken by a lot more bits I just hated.
I gave it a 4 over at IMDB. I’m not thinking I was too generous.
Sorry, Johnny. You killed the franchise all over again for a lot of us.




